Hello OpenBuilds community!
I am an intermediate DIY CNC’er at this stage. I started this journey about 5 years ago with a Grizzly Super X3 mill that I converted to CNC with a CNC Fusion ballscrew kit. Many, many thanks go to “Crevice Reamer” and “Priddy Shiddy” for the excellent write-ups on this setup. 5 years ago, there was much less information and resources available than there are now with OpenBuilds and many other DIY CNC resources. The SX3 does great for cutting parts within a 6”x14” window, but I have been searching for a larger work envelope solution for quite a while now.
I have been dreaming of ATC’s and eyeballing HAAS minimills and Tormach 770’s, but a planned move in the future make the debt and moving logistics untenable at this time for me. I was pretty intrigued by the price and envelope of the X-Carve when it came out, but the belt drives turned me away. Too much deflection and backlash for the metal-cutting precision I am accustomed to. Finally, in 2017, I stumbled upon the OpenBuilds C-Beam machine from a Ronin Energetics video on YouTube. I looked up the OpenBuilds site and immediately fell in love with the C-Beam X-large. The work envelope is perfect for some projects I have been dreaming up and the price is outstanding. Furthermore, there are many videos showing the aluminum cut quality that prove the practicality of the design. The portability of the design is another plus considering my current floor space limitations and future move. The SX3 needs to be moved with a cherry picker, which is cumbersome.
As I surveyed the design of the C-Beam XL, I noticed some aspects of the machine that I would change. The dual screws and steppers on the Y axis make me a bit uneasy. Steppers can miss steps independently of each other and that can lead to binding issues or misalignment. The Y axis support structure also allows a bit of cantilever from the bed under load from the spindle at the outer limits of travel.
My concept for improvement of the design eliminates one lead screw/stepper from the Y axis to provide a single stepper for the Y axis. The edges of the bed will be mounted to some V-slot rail which will be retained to the frame by a rigid plate attached to the frame edges. The single middle gantry plate and the two edge carriages retain the Y axis so that the spindle can only contact the bed between triangulated supports.
I would love to initially assemble the C-Beam XL as sold in kit form and to a test cut in aluminum on the lower-right hand corner of the work envelope, then do the same cut on my proposed modifications for a direct comparison. Being the unflappable cheapskate that I am, I might opt to just purchase the individual components of my design, we will see.
For added rigidity, the X-axis C-beam can be easily braced against deflection in the Y-axis. A simple brace would triangulate the extended X-axis c-beam to the frame edges without interfering with any bed/spindle travel. This is easy rigidity with no drawbacks. I will likely fabricate my own welded or machined brace, but a standard Home Depot shelf bracket (illustrated below) with some spacers underneath would work quite well. Mine would tie into the horizontal frame member, the vertical frame member, and the X-axis C-Beam.
I have attached my Sketchup model of the concept. Please forgive my shoddy Sketchup model, this is my first time using it. I usually use SolidWorks and Fusion360.
Dogmeat's Custom C-Beam XL
I love the C-Beam XL concept, this build is my custom version with the goal of increasing rigidity for metal milling.
- Build License:
- CC - Attribution - CC BY
Reason for this BuildTo cut large aluminum sheet metal parts
Inspired byMoag, Ronin Energetics